Group: sci.physics.particle
From: "Y.Porat"
Date: Wednesday, February 13, 2008 3:44 AM
Subject: Re: THE HIERARCHY PROBLEM - Mother of physics problem

On Feb 12, 4:15=A0pm, "Vince Morgan"
wrote:
> "Eric Gisse" wrote in message
>
> news:161e9569-d70b-4964-abe5-1f8bd6132031@b2g2000hsg.googlegroups.com...
> On Feb 11, 11:20 pm, "Y.Porat" wrote:
>
>
>
>
>
> > On Feb 12, 12:50 am, Zilla wrote:
>
> > > On Feb 12, 1:19 am, "Y.Porat" wrote:
>
> > > > On Feb 10, 7:02 am, Zilla wrote:
>
> >http://www.sciam.com/article.cfm?id=3Dthe-coming-revolutions-in-particl..=
.
>
> > > > > Btw... the articles about the Large Hadron Collider and coming
> > > > > revolutions
> > > > > in particle physics in Sci-Am mag are shared free in their site
> (full
> > > > > articles).
>
> > > > > The Hierarchy Problem and its solution is the top reason the LHC
> > > > > was built in the first place. And it is not just scaling the energ=
y
> > > > > up,
> > > > > it promises to discover new structures such as perhaps Santa Claus=

> > > > > being precipitated by the LHC or more exotic dimensional branes.
>
> > > > > I think the Hierarchy Problem can have analogy this way. In a
> > > > > boxing ring, it takes 10 rounds of time for the boxers to punch
> > > > > themselves around. Let's say the boxing ring is the interaction
> > > > > region or vertex of QED. In physics, what happens is that in
> > > > > 1 sec or less, all the punches in the 10 rounds happen at
> > > > > once. This is the magic of QED & QM. Now the Hierarchy Problem
> > > > > is the mystery how come a Muhammed Ali punch like an infant.
> > > > > That is, the Higgs can decay into top quark-anti-top quark pairs
> > > > > and because there are many paths, it can reach planck mass.
> > > > > But in reality the higgs mass to satisfy the electroweak theory
> > > > > is only very small. Why? =A0Who knows, the LHC may discover
> > > > > sequestering branes that protect the higgs from reaching the
> > > > > planck mass.
>
> > > > > It is surely interesting times ahead come July when the LHC
> > > > > becomes operational.
>
> > > > > I'm still perplexed why chiral symmetry can protect the masses
> > > > > of the fermions and bosons from the higgs hierarchy problem.
> > > > > Anyone kind enough to share?
>
> > > > > Zilla
>
> > > > ---------------------
> > > > 1
> > > > i thought that QM solved everthing !!.......
>
> > > > 2
> > > > have you heared about the idea of
>
> > > > 'The chain of orbitals ' =A0 =A0???
>
> > > > (3)
> > > > you quoted so many parroting nonsense
> > > > that beed a special prize from the Land of =A0nonasense
> > > > anyway it sowes clear as sun on midday
> > > > that no one undwerstands a fuck about what is =A0realygoing on there=

> > > > and it i squite clear to me that even the largest LHC
> > > > will not make it clearer
> > > > if there will be no some change in basic paradigms
> > > > like
> > > > 'no mass in physics '
>
> > > > because old catto saied :
> > > > 'No mass --no real physics '
>
> > > > ATB
> > > > Y.Porat
> > > > ------------------------------------------- Hide quoted text -
>
> > > > - Show quoted text -
>
> > > What nonsense? =A0It's just the tip of the iceberg.
> > > Physics middle name is strange and weird...
> > > btw... if you want to know too how chiral
> > > symmetry can protect the masses of the fermions
> > > and bosons from the higgs hierarchy problem.
> > > The answers are here:
>
> > >http://www.itep.ru/ws/2003/procs/Froggatt.pdf
>
> > > see the chapter "Fermion masses and mass protection".
>
> > > Also in here
>
> > >http://courses.washington.edu/phys55x/Physics%20558_lec2.htm
>
> > > specifically:
>
> > > "As we discussed last quarter, both vector particles and
> > > spin =BD particles naturally display symmetries that can
> > > ensure that they remain massless. =A0In the former case
> > > it is a gauge symmetry that plays this role. =A0As long
> > > as the gauge symmetry remains unbroken, there can
> > > be no interactions in the theory (i.e., terms in the
> > > Lagrangian, including a bare mass term) that give
> > > the vector gauge boson a mass. =A0The symmetry
> > > also ensures that this situation remains true even
> > > at higher order in perturbation theory. =A0In particular,
> > > radiative corrections in the form of loop diagrams
> > > (to be explained more thoroughly below) will not
> > > cause the vector gauge boson to acquire a mass.
> > > Likewise a Lagrangian with chiral symmetry
> > > (i.e., a Lagrangian where the right-handed fermions
> > > are treated independently from the left-handed
> > > ones) will exhibit massless fermions to all orders
> > > in perturbation theory. =A0Recall that the typical
> > > terms in the Lagrangian for a gauge theory,
> > > except for fermion mass terms, can be written
> > > separately for the different chiral components".
>
> > > Z.- Hide quoted text -
>
> > > - Show quoted text -
>
> > ---------------
> > my poor advaice to you is to learn the most basic
> > physics
> > **before you are fiddling with matheamtics**
>
> > the only good tip i can suggest to you
> > for basic physics is
>
> > no mass no real physics !!
> > just as simple as that !!!
> >Translated: "I don't understand how massless particles can possibly
> >exist, so they are wrong."
>
> Me too Eric.
> Seems like theories to support theories that don't add up to anything but
> the need for additional theory to explain a problem with the last addition=
al
> need for further additional theory. =A0If I had to eat this stuff I'd beco=
me a
> virtual person pretty quickly I think.
> No doubt all this stuff has been proven experimentaly?
> But as I don't get it I'm virtually stupid too I guess.
> Vince- Hide quoted text -
>
> - Show quoted text -

-------------------
virtual [particles has never been proven experimentall
in the location they are menst to exist

the were produces artificially in huge accelerators
with the porbability of one to a few billon
and ahs nothing to do with reallity

it seems that some of 'modern physics '
had reached new picks of crookedness!!
and stupidity
thanks to so 'witch Doctors' mathematicians
accompanied by experimental crooks -that are cheating the whole world
playing the Tam Tam drums ....

Y.Porat
-------------------------------------